Start with what students should learn and the evidence that will show it. Use a mix of practice, feedback, application, and reflection. Higher-level verbs alone do not make an assignment resistant to outsourcing: students need meaningful decisions to make and opportunities to explain them.
The revised Bloom’s taxonomy includes remember, understand, apply, analyze, evaluate, and create. Foundational knowledge supports more complex work; an effective assignment does not need to include every level. Explore Bloom’s taxonomy at Iowa State CELT.
About the lightbulb labels: The images below retain the original 1956 taxonomy: Knowledge, Comprehension, Application, Analysis, Synthesis, and Evaluation. The 2001 revision uses Remember, Understand, Apply, Analyze, Evaluate, and Create, placing Create after Evaluate. Both classify cognitive objectives; neither guarantees that an assignment cannot be outsourced to AI.
Knowledge
Comprehension
Application
Analysis
Synthesis
Evaluation
Use the optional assistant below to adapt one of these examples to your course. Provide the learning outcome, student context, assignment length, and AI-use boundaries. Ask for clear student directions and a short rubric.
PlayLab states that app creators can review usage. Do not enter student records or confidential information. Review generated suggestions before using them.
Open a section below for an activity with student directions, deliverables, AI boundaries, and assessment criteria. These are original examples for faculty adaptation, not research-tested guarantees.
Before assigning: supply the course materials or dataset, set the length and due dates, and align the criteria with your learning outcome. Offer equivalent accessible formats; audio or video should not be required when writing or another format demonstrates the same skill. Approved accommodations remain in effect.
Where an activity uses an AI response, an instructor-provided sample can remove the need for a student account. Ask for a short disclosure of permitted AI assistance, not an entire private conversation history.
Discussion: Make a Claim, Test It, Revise It
Learning goal: Apply a course concept, weigh evidence, and respond to an alternative interpretation.
Student task: “Using our case and this week’s readings, recommend one of the two proposed responses. Cite two specific details, explain a tradeoff, and identify one piece of information that could change your recommendation.”
Reply to a classmate who reached a different conclusion. Accurately summarize their reasoning before adding evidence or asking a question. End with a short revision explaining what you changed—or why you kept your recommendation.
Submit: Initial recommendation (about 200 words), one substantive peer response, and a 75–100-word revision note.
AI boundary: Draft your claim and peer response yourself. After drafting, you may ask AI to suggest a counterargument; verify it against the readings and disclose its use. An instructor-provided counterargument is an alternative.
Assess: Accurate use of the concept, relevant evidence, fair consideration of a competing view, and a reasoned revision. Do not grade agreement with the instructor.
Adapt it: History—interpret a primary source; biology—compare conservation plans; business—recommend a staffing approach; education—choose a response to a classroom scenario.
Learning goal: Interpret quantitative evidence and explain how a decision depends on assumptions.
Student task: “Use the provided fictional dataset to recommend which of two options best meets the stated goal. Show your calculations, create one labeled visual, and explain a limitation. Then change the assumption identified by your instructor and explain whether your recommendation changes.”
Submit: Annotated calculations or spreadsheet, one chart, and a one-page recommendation with the changed-assumption comparison.
AI boundary: Complete the first calculation and interpretation yourself. You may then use AI to check a formula or suggest an alternative; verify any changes and note what you accepted or rejected. Calculators and other permitted resources should be specified separately.
Assess: Correct method, accurate interpretation, explicit assumptions, and a defensible recommendation. Provide the dataset in an accessible table.
Learning goal: Build an interpretation from evidence rather than a summary alone.
Student task: “Choose a question raised by our two sources. Write an interpretation that uses a specific passage from each. Explain one tension between the sources and one reasonable alternative reading. Annotate a paragraph to show how the evidence supports your claim.”
Submit: A question and evidence notes, a 600–800-word analysis, and one annotated paragraph.
AI boundary: Develop the interpretation and write the analysis yourself. After drafting, AI may ask questions about clarity; it may not generate or rewrite the argument. A peer or writing-center consultation is an alternative.
Assess: An arguable claim, accurate reading, evidence-to-claim reasoning, and attention to a counterinterpretation.
Learning goal: Apply disciplinary standards under practical constraints.
Student task: “Using the fictional client brief, recommend a plan within its budget, timeline, and access requirements. Compare two options, justify your choice, and explain what you would change if one constraint changed.”
Submit: One-page brief, a comparison of two options, and a response to an instructor-provided change in circumstances.
AI boundary: AI may help brainstorm options. Verify standards and sources, make the recommendation yourself, and disclose assistance. Use only fictional client information.
Assess: Fit to the brief, disciplinary accuracy, tradeoff reasoning, and adaptation. Adapt to business, career education, public service, or teacher preparation.
Choose three to five course concepts, explain how they connect, and apply them to a course example. Create an accessible slide deck with clear headings, readable text, image descriptions, and labeled charts. Explain your choices through a captioned screen recording, a written presentation with speaker notes, or another equivalent accessible format that demonstrates the same outcome.
Set the length, permitted resources, and AI-use boundaries before students begin. Assess conceptual accuracy, evidence, connections, and the explanation of decisions. A presentation format alone does not establish independent authorship.
Adapted from a contribution credited to Anonymous.
Ask students to analyze a specific moment in a course video, connect it to a concept, and explain their interpretation using evidence. Some AI systems can process video, audio, and captions, so video is not an AI-proof assessment format. Keep accurate captions and provide a transcript or equivalent access; do not withhold accessibility features to limit AI use. Assess students’ reasoning through planned checkpoints or follow-up explanations.
Google DeepMind: Gemini 3.1 Pro model card documents video and audio inputs.
AI Literacy: Audit, Correct, Explain
Learning goal: Evaluate claims and improve an explanation using credible evidence.
Student task: “Read the instructor-provided AI response. Select three claims worth checking. Find and read the original source for each. Label each claim supported, partly supported, unsupported, or not yet verifiable, and explain your decision. Correct one important error and identify a limitation that remains.”
Submit: A claim–evidence table with working source links, a revised explanation (about 250 words), and a short account of the most consequential correction.
AI boundary: Everyone may use the supplied response without an external account. AI may suggest search terms, but a generated citation or a second chatbot’s agreement is not verification. Students make and explain the final judgments.
Assess: Quality of verification, accurate representation of sources, a justified correction, and appropriate acknowledgment of uncertainty.
Adapt it: Check a historical explanation, a scientific claim, a worked mathematical solution, or an advice memo. Use fictional or public material and avoid personal health or legal decisions.
Copy-and-adapt prompt: “I teach [course]. My students need to demonstrate [outcome]. Adapt [example from this page] into a [length or duration] activity. Use a [constructivist/cognitive/behavioral] rationale and explain how the activity reflects it. Include student directions, a deliverable, a feedback opportunity, and four observable assessment criteria. Students may use AI for [permitted uses] but must independently demonstrate [skill]. Provide an equivalent option without an external AI account and an accessible alternative to required audio or video. Identify any assumptions you made.”
Review before use: Does the task actually elicit the outcome? Is the theory connection accurate? Are the sources, workload, access requirements, and AI boundaries appropriate? Treat the output as a draft; the instructor makes the final decisions.
Adapt four criteria to your outcome: accurate use of course ideas, relevant evidence, explained decisions, and a justified response to feedback or changed conditions. Show students what each criterion looks like before they begin.
Choose the conditions needed for the learning goal. Independent work, discussion, practical demonstrations, and supported revision each provide different evidence. Offer equivalent accessible formats and make permitted resources explicit.
Peer Review: Explain the Revision
Learning connection: A constructivist approach makes room for another perspective; metacognition asks students to examine their own choices.
Student task: “Exchange a draft or solution with a partner. Identify one effective choice, one question, and one suggestion tied to our criteria. Revise your own work and explain which feedback you used or rejected, with a reason.”
Submit: Draft, brief peer feedback, revised passage or solution, and a 100-word decision note.
AI boundary: Write the peer feedback and decision note yourself. Do not upload a classmate’s work to an external tool. An instructor-provided sample can serve as an alternative when a partner is unavailable.
Assess: Specific feedback tied to criteria, a defensible revision, and an explanation grounded in the actual work.
Learning connection: A cognitive perspective asks whether students can use knowledge beyond the original example.
Student task: “After completing the original case, respond to a changed condition supplied by your instructor. Explain what still applies, what needs to change, and why.”
Submit: A short written explanation, annotated solution, or equivalent accessible demonstration.
AI boundary: Complete this transfer task independently using the resources specified by the instructor. Approved accommodations remain in effect.
Assess: Recognition of the changed condition, accurate application, and reasoning. Use this as planned evidence of learning, not a surprise interrogation about authorship.
Learning connection: Metacognition links monitoring with a concrete adjustment.
Student task: “Choose one error or weak decision from this assignment. Explain what led to it, identify a strategy that addresses the problem, and apply that strategy to a new example. Point to the part of your work that shows the change.”
Submit: The selected error, a 100–150-word plan, and the new attempt.
AI boundary: Write your diagnosis and reflection yourself. If permitted, AI may supply an extra practice example after the plan is written; verify it and disclose assistance. The instructor can provide an example instead.
Assess: A specific diagnosis, a strategy matched to it, and evidence of application—not a claim of effort or personal disclosure.
Use the form below to suggest an activity. Include the learning goal, student steps, AI-use expectations, and how you assess learning. Share only material you have permission to contribute and omit student information.